First Presbyterian Theater

2026-2027

• Hay Fever
• Middletown
  
• Side by Side by Sondheim
  
• District Merchants
  

2025-2026

• The Timekeepers
• Gift of the Magi
• What the Constitution Means to Me

2024-2025

• Disney's Beauty and the Beast
• Five Lesbians Eating a Quiche
• 26 Pebbles

2023-2024

• Bedroom Farce
• Head Over Heels
• Almost, Maine
• The Prom
• The Father
• A Star is Born (in Concert)

2022-2023

• The Greatest Showman (Revue)
• The Play That Goes Wrong
• Disenchanted
• The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
• Godspell
• Clybourne Park

2021-2022

• The Wolves
• The Bad Seed
• Sylvia

2020-2021

• Dark due to COVID-19

2019-2020

• Beyond Glory
• Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

2018-2019

• My Dead Clown
• Present Laughter
• Shaw Out Loud – The Doctor’s Dilemma
• Tom, Thom & Tommy’s Christmas Songs and Stories
• The Christians
• Twelfth Night
• Ben Butler

2017-2018

• Baskerville – A Sherlock Holmes Mystery
• Faith Healer
• Dickens’ A Christmas Carol
• RED
• Hamlet
• The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens, and Count Leo Tolstoy – DISCORD

2016-2017

• It’s Only A Play
• Ain’t Misbehavin’
• It’s a Wonderful Life – A Live Radio Play
• Heroes
• The Children’s Hour
• The Taming of the Shrew

2015-2016

• Escanaba in da Moonlight
• His Eye is on the Sparrow
• The Santaland Diaries
• The Zoo Story & The Duck Variations
• WIT
• One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest

2014-2015

• The Foreigner
• A Lesson Before Dying
• Christmas Potpourri
• The Savannah Disputation
• The Merchant of Venice
• Nunsense

2013-2014

• The Flattering Word
• Fox on the Fairway
• Mrs. Packard
• A NEW Christmas Revue
• Driving Miss Daisy
• Othello
• Misalliance

2012-2013

• God of Carnage
• Servant of Two Masters
• It’s A Wonderful Life
• Lion in Winter
• House of Blue Leaves
• Antony and Cleopatra

2011-2012

• Hi-Hat Hattie
• An American Christmas Carol
• Barrymore’s Ghost
• Shakespeare’s Will
• The Year of Magical Thinking
• You Can’t Take It With You
• Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

2010-2011

• The Laramie Project
• Tuesdays with Morrie
• The Christmas Spirit
• Dead Man’s Cell Phone
• As You Like It
• Broadway Bound
• The Lady with All the Answers

2009-2010

• You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown (1999 Revival)
• Romeo and Juliet
• A Walk in the Woods
• The FPT Christmas Revue
• The Way We Live Now – 20 Years Later
• Love Letters
• Harvey
• Murderers

2008-2009

• On Golden Pond
• Crowns
• It’s A Wonderful Life
• Boiling Pot
• Macbeth
• The Rabbit Hole
• The Underpants

2007-2008

• The Odd Couple
• The Twilight of the Golds
• It’s A Wonderful Life
• 1884 – An Historical Drama about Old Korea
• Much Ado About Nothing
• Doubt
• Mister Roberts

2006-2007

• The Little Foxes
• Equus
• It’s A Wonderful Life
• Don Juan in Hell
• The Merchant of Venice
• Steel Magnolias
• Rounding Third

2005-2006

• Our Town
• Two Gentlemen of Verona
• Amahl and the Night Visitors
• Eleemosynary
• Jesus Christ Superstar
• Lend Me a Tenor

2004-2005

• Sylvia
• Julius Caesar
• It’s A Wonderful Life
• No Exit
• Having Our Say
• How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
• Biloxi Blues

2003-2004

• Spinning Into Butter
• Ghosts
• The Christmas Schooner
• Three Viewings
• Fiddler on the Roof
• Measure for Measure
• Bleacher Bums

2002-2003

• Educating Rita
• Molly Sweeney
• The Christmas Schooner – A Musical
• Twelfth Night
• Godspell
• Arsenic and Old Lace
• Prisoner of Second Avenue

2001-2002

• Man of LaMancha
• A Midsummer Night’s Dream
• Art
• Brand
• The Mikado

2000-2001

• Children of Eden
• I Never Sang for My Father
• Actor’s Nightmare / Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All for You
• All My Sons
• Always, Patsy Cline

1999-2000

• The Pirates of Penzance
• Driving Miss Daisy
• Duck Variations / Imagining Brad
• Othello
• The Curious Savage

1998-1999

• Rip Van Winkle
• The Autumn Garden
• Agnes of God
• Jesus Christ Superstar
• The Good Doctor

1997-1998

• Our Town
• Tartuffe
• Diaries of Adam and Eve
• Three Tall Women
• Ruddigore or the Witch’s Curse

1996-1997

• The Foreigner
• Later Life
• The Miss Firecracker Contest
• Conversations With My Father
• Schoolhouse Rock, Live!

1995-1996

• Close Ties
• The Marriage of Bette and Boo
• Rehearsal for Death
• On Golden Pond
• Tintypes
• Rumplestiltskin (Lollipop Theatre)

1994-1995

• The Runner Stumbles
• The Dining Room
• Beau Jest
• Ghosts
• Little Mary Sunshine

1993-1994

• Mornings At Seven
• The School for Husbands
• The House of Bernarda Alba
• Blithe Spirit
• Godspell

1992-1993

• The Heidi Chronicles
• A Thousand Clowns
• Charley’s Aunt
• Wait Until Dark
• Red Hot and Cole

1991-1992

• Quartermaine’s Terms
• Two by Two
• A Trip to Bountiful
• The Teahouse of the August Moon
• A Shayna Maidel

1990-1991

• Whose Life Is It Anyway?
• You Can’t Take It With You
• Death of a Salesman
• Pygmalion
• Princess Ida

1989-1990

• The Miracle Worker
• Private Lives
• Three by Tennessee
• Not About Heroes
• Jacques Brel is Alive and Living in Paris

1988-1989

• Side by Side by Sondheim
• A Company of Wayward Saints
• Ah! Wilderness
• The Octette Bridge Club
• Sunday in the Park with George

1987-1988

• Painting Churches
• Amahl and the Night Visitors
• Butterflies Are Free
• God’s Favorite
• Good

1986-1987

• 84 Charing Cross Road
• The Curious Savage
• A Moon for the Misbegotten
• Lady Windermere’s Fan
• Spoon River Anthology

1985-1986

• Two Sisters
• Lovers
• The Rivals
• 'Night, Mother
• Trouble in Tahiti / The Telephone

1984-1985

• Mass Appeal
• After the Fall
• The Gingerbread Lady
• The Trojan Women
• The Gondoliers

1983-1984

• The Fourposter
• The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
• Hedda Gabler
• Zoo Story / The American Dream
• Pirates of Penzance

1982-1983

• The Subject Was Roses
• The Diary of Anne Frank
• Major Barbara
• The Last Meeting of the Knights of the White Magnolia
• HMS Pinafore

1981-1982

• Candida
• The Gin Game
• The Diviners
• The Night of the Iguana
• The Fantasticks

1980-1981

• Ghosts
• Pleasure and Repentance
• Life with Father
• Wings
• The Mikado

1979-1980

• Five Finger Exercise
• Winterthing
• The Antigone of Sophocles
• The Inspector General
• The Roar of the Greasepaint – The Smell of the Crowd

1978-1979

• Everything in the Garden
• The Matchmaker
• The Shadow Box
• Hay Fever
• Happy Prince / Old Maid and Thief

1977-1978

• Come Back Little Sheba
• Androcles and the Lion
• Exiles
• The Importance of Being Earnest
• Godspell

1976-1977

• Tea and Sympathy
• Years Ago
• The Great God Brown
• The Hasty Heart
• Help! Help! The Globolinks

1975-1976

• A Doll’s House
• The Thwarting of Baron Bolligrew
• The Elder Statesman
• Of Mice and Men
• No Exit
• Gideon

1974-1975

• Our Town
• Cocktail Party
• A Man for All Seasons
• Stop the World, I Want to Get Off

1973-1974

• The Typist / The Tiger
• A Delicate Balance
• You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown

1972-1973

• The Night Thoreau Spent in Jail
• A Company of Wayward Saints
• All My Sons
• Thurber Carnival
• The Apple Tree
• J.B.
• Dark of the Moon

1971-1972

• Electra
• Tortoise and the Hare
• The Trial of the Catonsville Nine
• The Grass Harp

1970-1971

• A Christmas Carol
• Spoon River Anthology
• Oedipus Rex
• Candida
• Rude Mechanicals

1969-1970

• Aesop’s Fables
• The Second Shepherd’s Play
• Fresh Cookies
• Let’s Make an Opera
• The Good Woman of Setzuan

1968-1969

• The Telephone
• Amahl and the Night Visitors
• Murder in the Cathedral (Performed in Sanctuary)